Adam or Kris: Who Will Be The Next American Idol?
Just in case you don’t know me yet….I am a HUGE American Idol and Dancing with the Stars Junkie. I can’t get enough. And So You Think You Can Dance. With Idol, I eagerly wait for it to start, bitch and moan through the auditions and boring rounds, and then get all sad when it’s about to end. Oh, and I heart Chris Daughtry and David Cook more than life itself.
It seems like only a few months ago that David Cook and David Archuleta were standing on the stage and Ryan announced that the winner was “David–” and my DVR cut off and I had to go online to find out who actually won.
But nope, it’s been a full year and we are about to crown the new American Prince Idol. I’ve made my feelings abundantly clear all season long so it will no surprise when I say GO TEAM KRIS!
For those of you that don’t know, I think Adam is insanely talented but you couldn’t pay me to buy his album and listen to that screaming. I do believe he should win, I just don’t want him to! And Kris has really come so far over the season. The “Dark Horse” (as opposed to the “dark goth”) continuously shocked the audience and judges—and me—week after week!
The finale had three rounds: singer’s choice, producer Simon Fuller’s choice, and crap-ass Official Single by Kara DioGuardi.
Who was your favorite? Who do you want to win? Who do you think should win?
Round 1
Artist’s favorite performance of the season
Adam Lambert “Mad World” Tears for Fears
One of the only performances of Adam’s that I really liked all season and was actually able to listen to from start to finish. I was really glad that he picked this one to revisit because there was no screaming! Simple, powerful, haunting and really amazing.
Kris Allen “Ain’t No Sunshine” Bill Withers
This is word-for-word what I said the last time he performed this song
His “Ain’t No Sunshine” is on par with David Cook’s “Hello” from last season. Both songs were very, very well known, pretty much out-of-date, cliched and “owned” by only one artist–meaning anyone else that tried to sing the song, sounded like a karaoke version of Bill Withers and Lionel Ritchie. But not these guys. They completely stripped it down, re-did it in a modern way and totally blew the song out of the water. It was un-real.
And it beared repeating becaue it blew me away all over again.
The only person that summed up my thoughts about his performance even better than I could was Kara DioGuaridi when she said: “If you can’t feel a Kris Allen performance and he doesn’t move you, then there is something wrong with you. You have a way of creating an intimate bond with everybody in the audience. You make us feel like you are singing to us”
Even better was Simon’s endorsement that yes, America got it right putting Kris in the finals.
Round 1 Winner (judges): KRIS!
Round 1 Winner (me): KRIS!!!!
Round 2:
Simon Fuller’s Pick
Adam Lambert “A Change is Going to Come” Sam Cooke
Why on earth Simon would pick this song is beyond me. IT is the most oversung song on Idol. I actually think Idol must get paid everytime someone sings that song because it is done at least once a season.
The judges were drooling all over themselves over his take and unique spin on the song.
I heard “Blah blah blah Scream Screech SCREAM SCREECH.”
Kris Allen “What’s Going On” Marvin Gaye
I love Kris because he doesn’t need fog, smoke, lights, high pitched screeches and guyliner to rock it out and be AMAZING!
The judges all thought it was too casual for a “night like this” I thought it was a huge risk to get up and just jam out. Let’s face it, he’s not Dave Matthews yet and it takes a lot of guts to get up in front of 7,000 live screaming people and come off chill and relaxed.
Round 2 Winner (judges): ADAM!
Round 2 Winner (me): Adam
but I don’t think that that he won it “a million times over” Kris like Simon said.
Round 3:
Their Will-Be Single
Adam Lambert “No Boundaries” co-written by Kara DioGuardi
I will officially boycott all radio stations for at least three years if Adam wins this competition because there is no way I can handle having to hear Adam’s bloodcurdling screechy version of that song every hour of every day.
From Mr. Cowell:
“You are one of the best, most original contestants we have ever had on the show. I genuinely believe we have found a world wide star in you.”
But he refused to critique his performance during Kara’s song. Because it freaking sucked.
Kris Allen’s “No Boundaries“ co-written by Kara DioGuardi
My tweet: “well crap. Kris’s voice just isn’t powerful enough for that arrangement of the song. I love him, but David Cook he is not.”
The problem was just what the judges said, the key was too high for him. I think if it was lowered just a bit he would have had an instant hit but I think he did the best that he could with a shitty song and the key.
That said, I would MUCH rather listen to that song every single hour of every day on the radio than Adam’s obnoxious version.
Round 3 Winner (judges): not revealed
instead the critiqued the season, not the performance, probably because they didn’t want to bash Kara’s crappy ass song.
Round 3 Winner (me): KRIS!!!!
——————-
My Winner:
GO TEAM KRIS!
What do you think? Who do you want to win?
Like
May 28th, 2009 at 7:33 pm
Thanks for posting, I truly enjoyed your most recent post. I think you should post more often, you evidently have natural ability for blogging!
May 28th, 2009 at 8:46 pm
Aw thank you! I’m planning on posting more, soon. I just started the Pink Bubble World part of Stiletto Sports so I’m still working on the time management part
I find that all I want to do is write here and not to my “real job work!”
May 30th, 2009 at 11:14 pm
thanks for stopping by my blog! i love my readers.
and yes … GO KRIS!! soooo glad he won! 
xoxo
May 31st, 2009 at 11:37 pm
Hey, thanks for commenting at my blog! The ‘underdog’ series was totally spurred on by Kris’s win, you know.
Did you read my post about said win? I’m still shocked…and divinely happy.
You have such a pretty space here. I shall return!
June 1st, 2009 at 10:36 pm
I did! I was so excited to see a piece that pulled sports AND kris together because my sports site was very dominated by Idol (and DWTS) for a few months! Thank you for your kind words! I have some fun pieces I’m working on in my free time….. stay tuned